Appraisal Case Studies

Another Fake Cartier Love: The Classic 4-Diamond Bracelet Examined

By Jessi, Concierge ·

A customer brought us a Cartier Love Classic bracelet with four diamonds, size 16, and asked whether it was genuine. After testing and comparing it side by side with a genuine bracelet, the conclusion was clear: it is a counterfeit. Here is what gave it away.

Two Cartier Love bracelets seen from inside under magnification: the genuine one above and the counterfeit below, with different engraving
Under magnification. Top: genuine. Bottom: the counterfeit.

1. The weight is off

The first check is the simplest: the scale. The genuine Love Classic bracelet (four diamonds, size 16) in our showroom weighs less than 29.11 g, which is what this bracelet weighed. Weight alone never proves anything, but a piece that does not match the genuine one is a reason to look harder.

The counterfeit Love bracelet on a small digital scale showing 29.11 grams
The counterfeit on our scale: 29.11 g.

2. The engraving is blunt and heavy

In a word, the engraving is very different from a genuine one. Cartier's genuine engraving is a very clean laser engraving, with thin, crisp, evenly formed lines. On this bracelet the engraving looks blunt and noticeably thicker.

Magnified inside view of a genuine Love bracelet (top) and the counterfeit (bottom) showing the © Cartier signature engraving
Top: genuine. Bottom: the counterfeit. The © mark and the Cartier script are visibly coarser on the counterfeit.

Magnified further, nothing matches the genuine bracelet, from the maker's marks to the lettering of the serial number and the gold standard mark.

Counterfeit engraving of the © mark and Cartier script, thick and rough under magnificationCounterfeit serial lettering under magnification, with rough, thick strokesCounterfeit gold standard and maker's marks under magnification, with rough edges
The counterfeit's engraving up close: thick, uneven strokes.

3. The screws fall short

The screws are the signature of the Love bracelet, and they are where a counterfeit tends to show its limits. Here the finish and quality are much lower than on a genuine bracelet.

Magnified comparison of a counterfeit Love bracelet screw on the left and a genuine one on the right
A second magnified comparison of the counterfeit screw on the left and the genuine screw on the right, showing the rougher slot and rim
Left: the counterfeit. Right: the genuine screw.

4. Real diamonds do not make it real

One more point worth knowing: the diamonds in this bracelet tested as natural diamonds. A counterfeit can carry real stones, so the stones alone say little about whether the bracelet is genuine. What matters is the whole piece: its weight, its engraving and its construction.

Diamond tester screen during the check of the counterfeit Love bracelet's stones
The diamond test on the bracelet's stones. They tested as natural diamonds.

Our conclusion

Weight, engraving and screws all pointed the same way, and the bracelet was judged to be a counterfeit. If you are unsure about a Cartier Love or any other piece of luxury jewelry, please come to ONE OF ONE and let us examine it in person.

Have a question about your jewelry?

For authentication, buying, selling, or any other question about your jewelry, please reach out to us below.

Chat with an Expert

← More in Appraisal Case Studies·← All articles