Appraisal Case Studies

Old Cartier Is Not Engraved Like New Cartier: A 1997 Trinity Ring Case

By Jessi, Concierge ·

When people check a Cartier piece, they usually compare it with what Cartier sells today. That works for a recent piece. For an older one it can point you in the wrong direction, because Cartier's engravings, marks and serial formats have changed over the years.

This is a Trinity ring that came in today. It was different from the current model, so we examined it carefully.

A vintage Cartier Trinity ring in three colors of gold, large model, on a black display pad
The Trinity ring we examined today.

No Cartier name on the outside

Cartier still makes the large Trinity today. In the current product photos we compared, the Cartier name appears on the outside of the bands. The ring we examined has no Cartier name outside at all.

What it has instead are two small marks. One is an eagle's head, the French official assay mark for 18K (750) gold, applied after the French state assay office tests the metal. The other is a diamond-shaped workshop mark, which identifies the workshop that made the piece.

Macro photo of the outside of a vintage Cartier Trinity ring band showing an eagle's head assay mark and a diamond-shaped workshop mark, with no Cartier name
Macro photo of the same two marks on another band of the same Trinity ring, a diamond-shaped workshop mark next to the eagle's head
The outside of the ring under magnification: the eagle's head and the diamond-shaped workshop mark, on two different bands. There is no Cartier name here.

A genuine large Trinity from the same period that we found abroad looks the same from the outside: the same kind of marks, and no Cartier name on the outer face.

The outside of a genuine large Trinity ring sold abroad, showing the same kind of marks and no Cartier name on the outer face
A genuine large Trinity sold abroad (photo from an overseas dealer's listing). Outer face: marks only, no Cartier name.

Inside: 750, Cartier, the size and a year

The Cartier name is on the inside of the band. There we find 750, the word Cartier in script, the ring size, and a copyright mark with the year 1997, followed by the serial number.

Macro photo of the inside of the Trinity ring band engraved 750, Cartier in script, and the ring size
Macro photo of the inside of the Trinity ring band showing a circled C copyright mark and the year 1997
Inside the band. Left: 750 and Cartier in script, followed by the size. Right: the © 1997 mark.

We read the year as pointing to the period the ring was made. The customer told us it was bought in Hong Kong in the 2000s. That fits what we see: a large Trinity made around 1997 that was still being sold from stock for some years afterward.

In fact, we found a ring engraved 1997 whose certificate shows a purchase date in 1998. A piece made in 1997 was not necessarily sold in 1997, so this is common.

Genuine examples abroad match

We looked for comparable pieces and found a genuine full set sold abroad, together with a Cartier certificate showing a purchase date in 1998. Its inside engraving follows the same pattern as the ring we examined.

The ring we examined: 750, Cartier, 59, © 1997. The genuine full set sold abroad: 750, Cartier, 52, © 1997. Only the size differs.

Macro photo of the inside of the Trinity ring band engraved 750, Cartier in script, and the ring size
The inside of a genuine large Trinity ring sold abroad, engraved 750, Cartier in script and the size 52
Left: the ring we examined. Right: the genuine full set sold abroad (overseas dealer's listing). Both read 750, Cartier, then the size.
Macro photo of the inside of the Trinity ring band showing a circled C copyright mark and the year 1997
The inside of the same genuine Trinity ring sold abroad, with the size 52 and a circled C copyright mark with the year 1997
Left: the ring we examined. Right: the genuine full set sold abroad. Both carry the © 1997 mark.
A Cartier certificate of authenticity sold with the genuine Trinity ring abroad, with a purchase date in 1998 and the numbers covered
The certificate sold with the genuine full set abroad, with a purchase date in 1998. Numbers covered.

We also found overseas listings of large Trinity rings from the same era whose engravings, inside and out, are almost identical to the ring we examined. Together this settled it for us. The ring was consistent with a genuine piece from that period.

The serial did not look like today's either

A current Cartier serial is a single run of letters and digits. On this ring the serial has six characters, but they are not run together the way they are on a current piece: two letters, three digits, a gap, then one more letter.

A genuine large Trinity from the same period that we found abroad carries a five-character serial. So even within one model the serial format varied, and it has changed over time.

Macro photo of the serial number engraved inside the Trinity ring we examined: two letters, three digits, a gap and one more letter
A genuine large Trinity ring sold abroad, whose serial number inside the band has five characters
Left: the serial on the ring we examined, six characters with a gap. Right: a genuine large Trinity sold abroad, with a five-character serial (overseas dealer's listing).

Another 1990s Trinity Classic, Another Engraving

The same day, another Trinity Classic from the 1990s came in. Its engraving also differs a great deal from what Cartier stamps today. It is not a fake. It is a difference between eras.

The inside of a genuine Cartier Trinity Classic ring from the same period, engraved 750 and 50, with a shield-shaped workshop mark
The inside of a Trinity Classic ring we examined, engraved 750 and 52, with a diamond-shaped workshop mark
Left: the inside of a genuine Cartier Trinity Classic from the same period. Right: the ring we examined. Both read 750 and the size, followed by a workshop mark.

The workshop marks differ slightly in shape. But the lettering inside each mark is the same, which tells us they are marks of the same workshop. Marks of one workshop were not always cut in exactly the same form.

Why this matters

A difference from the current model is not proof of a fake. Cartier changed where the name is engraved, what is stamped on the outside, and how serials are written, and a piece made in 1997 follows the rules of 1997.

The opposite is also true. A piece that matches today's engravings perfectly is not automatically genuine, because today's engravings are easy to copy. What counts is whether the markings match what Cartier actually used in the year the piece was made.

That is why vintage Cartier takes an archive. You need genuine pieces from many years in front of you to know which markings belong to which period.

Our verification process

We examine every hallmark, workshop mark, engraving and serial under magnification, compare them with genuine pieces and with certificates from the same period, check the weight and test the metal. When something does not match the current model, we do not stop at “different.” We work out which period the piece belongs to.

Want to sell vintage Cartier jewelry?

Even without a box or certificate, we will examine your piece carefully and pay promptly if it is genuine.

We're at 336 Apgujeong-ro, Unit 109, Seoul. Please contact us at +82 10-8995-7062.

Have a question about your jewelry?

For authentication, buying, selling, or any other question about your jewelry, please reach out to us below.

Chat with an Expert

← More in Appraisal Case Studies·← All articles